Janet could sing a Nirvana track?
 

Probably for the Heroes part. That's the rumour anyway as supposedly Courtney Love has given the go ahead.

If true its bad news for Janet I think. Firstly alot of Nirvana fans hate XF probably so there will be a backlash there and more importantly, could Janet pull of a Kirt Cobain track? Maybe only something like 'Lithium' and if people are already complaining about boredom this sort of song would risk suicide. I'd love for her to give it a shot, but think its a bad idea if she wants to win.

Oh I love Nirvana :amazed: But, yeah, I see your point. Maybe About a Girl?

That would be really cool. In her own style she probably could pull off some other songs too. Come As You Are would be one.

She could do nirvana quite well, i reckon. What I'd really like her to sing, barely relevant to any of this, is 'nothing compares to you' by Sinead O'Connor. I think she'd be amazing at that! 'Guilty pleasure' maybe?

Yeah, that would probably better, people might have heard of that :laugh: As much as I love Nirvana though, I don't know if it will appeal to general public

Or Heart Shaped Box (though would XF like her singing lyrics like 'i wish i could eat your cancer when you turn black' lol. Yeah not sure if the general public who mostly like chessy crappy pop like Cher Lloyd (snore) would really be into this kind of thing. However if she is to lose, then so be it. At least lose with her general fanbase in tact for her trying such a thing :)

Yeah, you're right. I would be more inclined to buy her stuff if she did Nirvana type stuff, rather than the cheese they'll give her if she wins

Two awful acts put together to make one explosion of suck

OMG, did you just diss Nirvana? :shocked:

http://www.gifshare.com/uploads/imag...scrubsslap.gif

You know I don't like Nirvana :joker:

You have no taste then :hmph:

Hint that Janet may play guitar too. If so can really see her performing Come As You Are acoustic version.

:amazed: or Polly maybe?

Would love to hear her sing Pennyroyal tea. Think that would be awesome :D

Oh, yeah good choice. I really want her to sing Nirvana now :amazed:

Other band I could see her playing is red hot chilli peppers.

:amazed: They're my second favourite band. I went to see them live a couple of weeks ago.

This would be a good one for the Chili Peppers :

Yep. Great band. Supposedly Janet 's fave so would fit in with heroes part of it.

Then this would happen

Simon Cowell isn't a judge anymore karl :idc:

But his point is completely valid

Depends in what way Janet sings it really and she isnt really a sell out as its the production fault for a heroes based theme if Janet's heroes are to do with rock :D

At the end of the day, Janet can sing what she wants whteher it be Nirvana or Red Hot Chili Peppers and actually Simon was stupid up there because hes basically saying no one should sing a Rock song for their audition or on the live show when we have had a Rock based theme already featuring Guns N Roses another band who wouldn't exactly explore his show :D.

I would rather listen to them sing that type of music and I'm a viewer :hmph: