X Factor Finalists - Wishing On a Star
 

I know it's for a good cause but this really is dull and their vocals have been so overproduced (in particular Janet, Craig and Marcus). One Direction and JLS make it even worse, their addition is completely pointless and clearly done because the producers are worried that it won't get to number one without their fanbases. :bored:

Thoughts?

I think it's my least favourite x factor charity single... They've made the autotune so obvious, sounds quite bad. I thought the song from the m&s ad was their charity one so I'm a bit disappointed :(

JLS and 1D shouldn't be in this either...

JLS and 1D? wtf are they doing in it :bored:

Im really happy Sophie got a lengthy part, she sounds amazing and has a great recording voice!

Marcus sounds ridiculous... and there needs to be more shots of the other acts its well biased. I also dont like how they make Jesy, Jade and Leigh look like backing singers to Perrie.

Are they performing this tonight/tomorrow?

The bit in the childrens home was filmed literally down the road from me :)

1D and JLS were completely pointless and I mentioned this on Twitter and got a load of hate messages for doing so. :/

Much prefer their M/S advert song.

It's crap!

It isn't very good. Although Perrie sounds amazing.

She really does but they made the other 3 looks irrelevant :bored:

Tomorrow

Yeah, which is a shame.

Now at #1 on iTunes

The live show of the song was appaling,Sophie and Amelia were by far the best though.

On the show I wondered WTF JLS and One Direction were there for. They walked on and it finished :conf:

I know,but at least my ears was saved.

Indeed. Small mercies

Sophie back on TXF :lovedup:

#1 in the midweeks