was adam right to hold tobacco from ash?
 

I thought he played it superbly

tha foul mouthed sub human ashleigh, was fully supportive of carolines unoriginal unhilarious sabotaging of the shopping....yet when there was only a tiny bit of tobacco , she soon demanded it....she should have said yes it was her who helped caroline ruin the weekly shopping and therefore she should forfeit her bit of tobacco....

adam made this point clearly and fairly and still gave her a share

she of course grabbed it ....what a brainless bore she is

another moral victory for adam:wavey:

I think he was right!! She doesn't even smoke that much anyway!:pipe:

As much as I dislike her, no. Its not his place, all smokers are entitled to their fair share, he isn't in charge imo.

she encouraged caroline to destroy the £550 shop? was that her place to do that? she was too cowardly to stop it? as were the other insiders.

She knew Caroline was planning on sabotaging the shopping list and thought it was hilarious. Adam gave Ashleigh her share of the tobacco in the end any way. So what's the problem? She's not even a proper smoker.

He was right to keep it, she doesn't really smoke, and she knew about Caroline not putting tobacco on the shopping list, i would of kept it too, she kept it from the smokers what caroline was doing with the shopping so they were right to keep the tobacco, i don't know why Luke S were telling her she has a right to have some tobacco when he hates Ash smoking he just likes a fight.

She didn't know Caroline wasn't getting any fags though, she even told her to make sure she got some, not really Adam's place to take control of the cigarette supply

:worship: and even with persuasion, the list would have still been sabotaged. Caroline had her mind set.

no :bored:

he is a ****

Adam did the right thing it should have taught her a lesson,and he gave some to her after a while,which is more than i would have done,she is opne of those people who Have to get thier mitts on anything other people have,plus on LF Luke S was telling her NOT to give 'someone' fags not sure who it was,but shows they are so thick they learn nothing.

And I dont get this whole 'she doesnt even smoke that much' nonsense. The tabacco is for everyone, from casual to hard smokers.

Does anyone know roughly how many a day each of them smoke?

Adam went down in my estimation after this. But Ashleigh's counter-argument was weak and she didn't express herself very well (as usual). She was trying to say it was never her intention to have no cigs and it was Caroline who made the decision when she was in the DR. But she isn't very articulate and just got in a strop like a child. Glad he saw sense and decided to give her her share. Luke S was worse imo for getting involved. It had nothing to do with him and he's not even a smoker.

Well why didn't the stupid dumb cow go to the diary room herself and ask for some ! she took no cigs in and then continually scrounged cigs Lauren had paid for - she also had the neck to have a go at Lauren for complaining about it. *******igh don't even inhale - what a waste of cigs and tobacco , esp when it is so expensive. I would have told her to sod right off - Skank

Realistically by any proper standards her 'fair share' consists of a portion commensurate with how many a day she smokes, which is WAAAY less than a fifth.

She really is a complete leech.

Absolutely, she knew what Caroline was up to, she faces the consequences, and she's a sket, if only she walked :idc:

He wussed out and gave her some anyway.

Yeah, exactly she thought SHE was getting some. She made it clear that she thought she was going to be the only one getting some. When it backfired on her she had no right demanding some from the others.

Did BB not insruct him to do so? I thought someone else said that?

No, he made his point, and got her to think about how her and her friends actions affected others, then he divided it up. Win, win for Adam, he got his point across and then showed he was better than them.:hugesmile:

He still wussed and gave her some. No matter how you wrap it up dear.

I think the crowd should all make sucking sounds when she leaves the house:devil::devil:

She asked Caroline but Caroline later explained that if she got tobacco she would have to get it for all the smokers...then if she did that then she would have had to have got protein powder etc.... so she had to leave it all together.

Lets not forget when Ashleigh etc drank the wine in the cudboard...Adam did good to wind her up. He did eventually give her some.

If that is true, she's still a horrid little get, when realising Caroline hadn't got them she didn't have a go at her but soon found her voice to kick off with Adam.

Adam=pussy