Worst judge?
 

Gary for me. Has just become a bit of a dick now and doesn't really offer anything constructive/very hypocritical about Rylan given he put Frankie through last year.

Tulisa trashy as always too

Tuslia is terrible in every way

Louis

Easily

Nicole
Louis
Gary
Tulisa

Gary.

Tulisa is the best judge.

Louis. Ruins whatever category he has with crap song choices, doesn't give that good feedback & only likes performances if they're fun/camp.

Frankie was better than Rylan in every way...

Tulisa
Nicole
Louis
Gary

Tulisa has been a bit poor this series.

Gary is a ******* as well.

Louis > Nicole > Gary > Tulisa

Louis

Just no...

Rylan at least attempted to sing in-tune at Judges Houses.

Frankie couldn't sing at all though :joker: Just stood around trashed basically talking

Rylan is actually performing/can actually sing a little bit

Louis. Been the worse judge for years. God knows how he mentors MK1. He knows nothing about their kind of music.,

Well Louis is the best judge and mentor. Nicole has surprisingly been decent. Gary is Louis' sidekick so can't hate on him too much. And Tulisa has sort of just been there this year, not really involved in any of the funny moments and is pretty boring. So her.

we have the same opinion on everything :shocked:

it's scary

gary

Louis..I don't dislike him, but he's a poor judge; just really out of touch.

Tulisa comes second for me

Whatever he did was entertaining

What Rylan does......is not entertaining

And he could actually sing a bit

To say Rylan can sing, rofl

People dancing in panda costumes is better than Frankie doing a dodgey half arsed Queen cover

Should have put multiple choice so I could vote Tulisa as well. Should never be near a show like this when your experience is being in a woeful group such as N Dubz

Gary,I cannot bear him on X Factor.
I think he is a great songwriter and a good singer and I really like Take That but I can see how Robbie Williams had problems with Gary, dealing with him must be a nightmare.

There'd be no entertainment on the panel without Gary and Louis and that's a fact, so they're discounted from this poll as a result.

I've surprisingly liked Nicole so far actually, I didn't rate her on XF USA but it seems she does suit the UK more after all. I did/do like Tulisa and would've probably said she was the best new judge last year but she seems almost bored this time around, and hasn't involved herself as much yet. So for me it's a toss up between the girls.

Quite like them all actually.

Tulisa seems to know her acts most, and work with them well.
Nicole is surprisingly quite fun.
Louis despite the ****tery last week, is a laugh and part of the furniture. Probably the worst 'mentor' however.
Gary has gone from being a twat last series to giving some good grounded shouts.

Gary Borelow.