Best judge?
 

Nicole has taken me by surprise...funny too

toss up between nicole and tulisa

Louis>Gary>Tulisa>Nicole

like them all though.

Gary :)

Gary/Tulisa

Nicole

Louis and Gary are great as well

Gary has been on form this year

Tulisa.

One last year not just with a group but with a girlgroup, and is looking likely to win once again :worship:

Louis <3.

But Nicole could soon over-take.

The other two need replacing.

Alaways liked Louis as a Judge, only one I cannot stand this series is the same is last year too and that's Gary.

Gary for me,says it as it is.

Nicole was a pleasant surprise.

Nicole was on fire tonight. She's shaping up as the best judge this year. I've always loved Louis and Tulisa says it as it is but Gary really is a boring old fart. I like him well enough - but not as an X Factor judge (would love to see Robbie W instead...)

Gary is actually looking for talent unlike the rest of them, though I can see him leaving after this year.

Nothing in it between Louis and Gary, they make the panel with their banter and bitching. Gary's no Simon of course but if we didn't have him there'd be no sniping comments, he's the next best thing. Louis is just a legend and can never be replaced.

I've quite liked Nicole so far this year which is surprising when I wasn't excited by her signing. I've actually gone from last week saying it was a really dull panel to thinking it might have some life in it after all, I think after last week's drama it's livened up a bit.

Tulisa, BUT i really like Nicole as well, she's funny!!

For some reason, Tulisa seems like a bit of a wet fish this year.

She already seems bored of doing it, wouldn't be suprised if she left after this series.

All pretty poor imo. Bring back Danni, Cheryl and Simon, not gonna happen but still.

Lily Allen would be a great judge.

Nicole or Louis. Tulisa's meh, Gary's far too in Simon Cowell's pocket.

best judge
onkar judge

Don't like any of them, but I chose Nicole.