ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums - The Girls Are The Best Singers

ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/index.php)

- The X Factor 2012 [S9] (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=602)

- - The Girls Are The Best Singers - Say Experts (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/showthread.php?t=214640)

The Girls Are The Best Singers - Say Experts

http://www.entertainmentwise.com/new...es-Say-Experts

Quote:

Despite all the critique he gets for being "dated" and "cheesy", Christopher Maloney is still often praised for the strength of his singing ability.

However, pitch-perfect analysts from 63336 have revealed that he turned in the WORST vocal performance on last night's show, hitting more bum notes than the heavily-criticised Rylan Clark and District 3.

In fact, in joint second place is Kye Sones - meaning it was both of Gary Barlow's acts who failed to keep their vocals in tune.

Heavily praised Jahmene Douglas is also in second, along with Rylan.

Ella Henderson was apparently the best performer, hitting only two bum notes. Jade Ellis, despite being savaged during her judges' critique, is the second best, with three dodgy notes.

The list in full:

1. Christopher Maloney - 10 bum notes
=2. Kye Sones - 8
=2. Rylan Clark - 8
=2. Jahmene Douglas - 8
=5. District 3 - 6
=5. James Arthur - 6
7. Union J - 5
8. Jade Ellis - 3
9. Ella Henderson - 2

"Each week everyone likes to debate if the judges got it right or wrong with little real analysis of the performances,” explained Helen Wright, General Manager of 63336.

"63336 used dedicated researchers to analyse each act and found that Christopher Maloney really struggled the most this week, missing notes in both the high and low registers. He was surprisingly even more out of tune than Rylan, whom many people discount as the show’s weakest singer.

"In reality Rylan sang fairly well in tune, hitting the same number of flat notes as both Kye and even show favourite Jahmene."

Interesting!

At least now we've got a definite answer of who's the most talented!:cheer:

Hard to determine though, could be nervous on the night or have a safe song

think we will need a second opinion here

this is based only on bummed notes. Oh nevermind, thread is invalid

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roy Mars III (Post 5571676)

this is based only on bummed notes. Oh nevermind, thread is invalid

Why's it invalid? Because you're favourites are last? :cheer:

James Arthur is fourth

Funny, I thought that Christopher was your favourite? It certainly says that in your favourites :conf: Unless you've been saying that to wind members up which would be rather odd...

You don't need an expert to tell you that the girls are the best.

You can't prove who has the most talent.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flamingjoe (Post 5571688)

You don't need an expert to tell you that the girls are the best.

Totally, most of us with a reasoned head on can see that District3, Maloney, Rylan are the worst ones by far.

I normally support the girls, but the boys are the most talented this year. James Arthur & Jahmene are great. Obv Rylan isn't but had Adam/Joeseph made it.

i'm the only expert you need to listen too

Lol that is fake as Rylan hit a few more bump notes than they are saying imo.

Oh I misread it lol.

I'm sorry but you can't base the quality of somebodies voice purely on being pitch perfect. A great performer is much, much deeper than that.

According to this Union & Jade are better than James.....This means nothing to me :laugh:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brother Leon (Post 5571832)

According to this Union & Jade are better than James.....This means nothing to me :laugh:

u mad?

No surprise Ella is 1st :pipe: