no longer a contender?
 

He's getting blander - big band was supposed to be his baby buble week but most others out did him, I actually think saM b may pinch some of his "mum" votes which leaves Scottish vote, I can see sam being on b2 in semi final.

He does nothing for me. But he'll always get good comments, no matter if he's good or bad in the show. :bored:

Hes not hit B2 so you cant assume that yet.

Exactly he was very crap last week and luke good, yet judges praised him to high heaven. Weirdly when asked who her fav boy was she said loved luke then paused and then added nicholas, it was as if she forgot the script

No worries. If Luke is amazing next week, but gets bad comments the fans will vote more to keep him in. :p

No but sam b looks 100% safe to final snd rough copy in polls are catching him up and will probably over take. Louis has a generic formula with Nicholas and is sticking with it. He can sing but it's so samey and bland. His main issue is actually he's like two winners: he's a mixture of Joe MCElderry (100% in tune reliable squeaky clean but bland performances) and Leon Jackson (charisma- free, reliable Scottish crooner). Not sure public will bite for this type of winner again.

I think he's a fantastic little singer and has been since the start.

Luke is also great but I think his song choice let him down this week so I disagree with your OP and think the judges responses were spot on.

I loved the fact luke was the only one trying to do someyhing a bit different with big band and therefore not karaoke. He knows he's not destined to make a big band coverd album just in time for Mother's Day. :joker:

Nicholas will always be a contender, but I am taking a bet on him to go on next Saturday as I want to get loads of money.:joker: