Different kinds of pundits
 

I know even Liverpool and Man City fans praise Gary Neville's punditry on Sky, but I would like to see other kinds of pundits eg refs, managers, football journalists, bloggers etc.

There used to be non footballer pundits now it all ex pros (and some cuurent pros) with the occasional sacked manager. As good an insight some ex players can give things have gone a bit cosy and a bit stale, with even rival players ganging up on refereeing decisions. It's got too homogenous and samey, would like to see alternative view points.

Neville said that Moyes appointment was bang on right and the best one for united....

listen to H&J from 1pm on Talksport for non player comment and opinion.

Thats where the radio and podcasts come in useful, opinions from all different types of people.. Fans, refs, players, ex players, managers, journalists..

Ban Jamie Redknapp basically


And Dwight Yorke

Neville has been ****e recently. Too scared to criticise anything now he's a coach, and keeps having goes at the media even though he is part of the media now

Roy Keane is obviously the best pundit :idc:

Nobody beats Keano. Has a go at anyone and everyone. :smug:

Roy is just controversial for the sake of it and speaks **** 90% of the time

Same with Souness

Dixon needs to go to a channel where he will get more airtime, think he is better than Neville

That man is permanently on the verge of rage :hugesmile:

Spanish football have the best commentators and pundits.

Was better without Minto

Graham Hunter's reputation has gone down the pan after the Thiago saga last summer hasn't it?

Monday night club with chappers on 5 live is great and so is Saggers evening show on TS

:joker:

Agree about Roy. He speaks honestly and is not afraid to offend which can be great. However it's as if he knows his appeal is controversy and is almost chomping at the bit for Adrian Chiles to feed him a question which allows him to be controversial.

:nono:

Roy's best moment for me. Ian Wright's reaction. :joker:

haha at wrighty

classic

Neville has been dreadful with everything involving United this season and generally pretty poor. Lost count how many times he shies away from criticising English players.

And not criticising Moyes.