Sugababes: Keisha vs Jade
 

who sang better/which do you prefer on these songs?:spin:



















prefer Keisha on them all :hehe:

way to much effort soz

Keisha. Though I liked Jade as a Sugababe.

Keisha is my fave member of Sugababes :love:

Jade hew? Goody?

keisha

Keisha. who is jade?

poll added, awaiting Z's dissertation.

Keisha every day of the week. Jade's possibly the most technically gifted singer ever to be in the Sugababes but her voice doesn't suit being in a group in my opinion. She has a sort of stage school voice that's best suited to musicals, same as Heidi Range but Heidi fits into a pop group environment because her voice isn't so overpowering. Jade's is.

:laugh: Kept it to half a paragraph for once!

Jade's voice in Miss Everything though :umm2::umm2::umm2:

didn't Heidi thirst to become a member of a pop group

She was in Atomic Kitten before I think :think:

this song should be made a hymn in all local churches

umm shade for Gimme More?

Apparently that's not strictly true. Heidi, Liz McLarnon and Kerry Katona were provisionally put in a group together called Honeyhead but Heidi dropped out before anything was formalised, they found Natasha and rebranded as Atomic Kitten.

why would you sing a passage from the bible?

at least she wasn't replaced by Kerry Katona, she'd never live down that :laugh:

it's that goood - it should be in every gospel to liven it up

Heidi, Keisha and Mutya >> MKS hew?

I think switching to Sugababes worked out better for Heidi in the end :laugh: I'm not sure she would have cared

HKM era > but Siobhan is a better vocalist and is more unique to the group

Prefer Jade in Wear My Kiss but Keisha in the rest

I voted the same :hehe:

Siobhan can't do sexually suggestive in performances and videos; Heidi can. That's literally the only thing Heidi brought to the group that Siobhan couldn't/can't. Siobhan's a superior vocalist.