ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums

ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/index.php)
-   BB15 (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=647)
-   -   Rank the housemates in order of relevance to the series (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/showthread.php?t=261458)

Headie 13-08-2014 12:12 PM

Rank the housemates in order of relevance to the series
 
Which housemates have been the most relevant to the series and actions/incidents in the house, and which housemates had practically no relevance at all to what went on?

(R) = Relied on others to be relevant/Relevant due to others' actions towards them)

1. Helen
2. Ashleigh
3. Steven
4. Mark
5. Pauline
6. Toya
7. Kimberly (R)
8. Danielle
9. Biannca
10. Jale (R)
11. Christopher (R)
12. Chris
13. Matthew (R)
14. Winston
15. Marlon
16. Ash (R)
17. Zoe
18. Pav (R)
19. Tamara

As much as I liked Matthew, he wouldn't have been relevant without Mark or Helen there tbh. The ones that were there for less than 3 or 4 weeks, I just judged them on how relevant they were during their short stay (Tamara/Biannca/Toya/Pauline)

mrflibble 13-08-2014 12:18 PM

It depends which actions/incidents each person finds relevant. I never care about the main storyline, so I follow and care about other things going on. I'm not really sure how I'd rank that, tbh. If it was purely on housemates relevance to how I've viewed the series + my enjoyment, then maybe something like this:

1. Chris
2. Pauline
3. Ashleigh
4. Christopher
5. Helen
6. Jale
7. Mark
8. Matthew
9. Steven
10. Kimberly
11. Danielle
12. Toya
13. Ash
14. Winston
15. Biannca
16. Zoe
17. Pav
18. Marlon
19. Tamara

Sophiee 13-08-2014 02:55 PM

1) helen;
2) ashleigh;
3) christopher;
4) mark;
5) pauline;
6) matthew;
7) steven;
8) toya;
9) danielle;
10) chris;
11) zoe;
12) ash;
13) jale;
14) biannca;
15) kimberly;
16) winston;
17) marlon;
18) pav;
19) tamara.

I don't think you can say some of them only had relevant because of another housemate, because you could just as easily flip that around.

Headie 13-08-2014 03:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sophiee (Post 7163712)

I don't think you can say some of them only had relevant because of another housemate, because you could just as easily flip that around.

The reason I said that is mainly because one HM would cause the talking points but the other would be linked to it by association (e.g. Kimberly & Steven). You have Kim quite lower than Steven yet she was pretty relevant to this series, however when she wasn't with Steven she was quite irrelevant. And you can't flip that around and say Steven was only relevant due to Kimberly's actions as he wasn't, it was mainly him. Hope that makes my point/meaning a bit clearer :p

Babayaro. 13-08-2014 03:29 PM

1) Helen
2) Ashleigh
3) Steven
4) Mark
5) Christopher
6) Danielle
7) Pauline
8) Kimberly
9) Toya
10) Chris
11) Jale
12) Ash
13) Winston
14) Marlon
15) Pav
16) Matthew
17) Zoe
18) Biancca
19) Tamara

Jack_ 13-08-2014 03:38 PM

1) Helen
2) Ashleigh
3) Steven
4) Mark

[ ^ stars of the series, should've been the F4]

5) Christopher
6) Danielle
7) Pauline
8) Toya
9) Jale

10) Biancca
11) Kimberly
12) Chris
13) Ash

14) Marlon
15) Winston

16) Matthew
17) Pav
18) Zoe
19) Tamara

I split them up to show how they're grouped by relevance also

JoshBB 13-08-2014 03:50 PM

1) Helen
2) Toya
3) Pauline
4) Biannca
5) Mark
6) Steven
7) Jale
8) Danielle
9) Christopher
10) Ashleigh
11) Winston
12) Pav
13) Zoe
14) Matthew
15) Tamara
16) Kimberly
17) Chris
18) Ash
19) Marlon

abhorson 13-08-2014 04:04 PM

Bianca would be my last. Five days of not much unless you like flesh.

M X 13-08-2014 04:35 PM

1. Ashleigh
2. Helen
3. Mark
4. Christopher
5. Steven
6. Kimberly
7. Danielle
8. Chris
9. Jale
10. Biannca
11. Toya
12. Ash
13. Winston
14. Zoe
15. Pauline
16. Matthew
17. Pav
18. Marlon
19. Tamara

jessicadanielle 13-08-2014 04:42 PM

Can I ask what people found so relevant about Steven? Genuine question. I just found him annoying from time to time, and without his Kim storyline, I don't know what else he brought to the show. What parts do people find memorable about Steven?

M X 13-08-2014 04:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jessicadanielle (Post 7163995)
Can I ask what people found so relevant about Steven? Genuine question. I just found him annoying from time to time, and without his Kim storyline, I don't know what else he brought to the show. What parts do people find memorable about Steven?

The question is about relevance, not who you like the most. Even if it was only one thing, Steven's relationship with Kimberly dominated a lot of the show and then also the aftermath of her exit.

jessicadanielle 13-08-2014 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MichaelSpears (Post 7164000)
The question is about relevance, not who you like the most. Even if it was only one thing, Steven's relationship with Kimberly dominated a lot of the show and then also the aftermath of her exit.

I know but I don't think their relationship is all that relevant to the show tbh. I suppose I just used to switch off when he started going "you know I love you, don't you?" again :laugh:

I'm not asking this because I don't like him. I couldn't stand Pauline but I appreciate she was highly relevant to how the show has panned out

Babayaro. 13-08-2014 06:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jack_ (Post 7163821)
1) Helen
2) Ashleigh
3) Steven
4) Mark

[ ^ stars of the series, should've been the F4]

5) Christopher
6) Danielle
7) Pauline
8) Toya
9) Jale

10) Biancca
11) Kimberly
12) Chris
13) Ash

14) Marlon
15) Winston

16) Matthew
17) Pav
18) Zoe
19) Tamara

I split them up to show how they're grouped by relevance also

lol our top 9 are basically the same


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:51 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.