Time to ban singers?
 

We have half a dozen shows aimed at singers so they need to ban them from the show as it is ruining the chances of a talented variety act

The judges should just put less through to the semis

Simon got rid of half he variety acts for being on other shows but kept singers who have been

.

I think non conventional singing acts are fine, but yes solo singers should be culled. Especially if X Factor is going back to it's 14+ roots.

Singers will always get put on because they're more ratings friendly than your dance troupes or your mime acts.

The X Factor for the singing world also knows that Diva singers, boybands, and joke acts pull in the most viewers going into the lives sadly a more interesting lineup on these shows might not nesscessarily draw in the masses immediately.

but you love joke acts


btw a joke act had won the German Idols, Alphonse Williams, 55 years old :D

Pop singers who wouldn't last 2-3 weeks in X Factor, yeah. But you've got to remember the prize isn't really a record contract they've just got to be able to perform at the RV. So all your kid singers/classical acts will always be there because it's something Queeny would like, unfortunately

Yes, I think many of the singers could take their chance on X Factor or the voice.
A good point Adam.