Originally Posted by Cal. (Post 9500099)

Second Chance Housemates:
Isabelle: Would have been evicted like Sam.
Savannah: Been evicted in a similar fashion to Charlotte.
Tom: Made it to the final and won the 15k like Andrew

Actual HMs:
Sam: Made it to the final
Andrew: Been evicted in the first month
Simone: Been evicted in the first month
Sue: Been evicted in the first month

Originally Posted by Daniel-X (Post 9500090)

one of Sue/Andrew/Simone got voted in instead of Tom and Sam got in instead of Isabelle/Savannah.

I think if Isabelle/Savannah/Tom were second chance housemates:

Isabelle: would've been evicted in a similar fashion to Sam, she wouldn't be ruthless enough to win
Savannah: wouldve been evicted by the public probably, idk though about Savannah this is the only one I had struggle predicting
Tom: think he would've won, he's shown to be quite ruthless before and I don't think he would've hesitated to snatch the money

I think if Andrew/Sam/Simone/Sue were actual HMs:

Andrew: would've been evicted either when Rebecca, Savannah or Joe was, the public obviously don't like him
Sam: would've been in the final
Simone: would've been evicted by the public as soon as she was up
Sue: same as Simone