If Isabelle entered on day 1, do you think she would have won?
 

I think part of her win was when she came in and took out Lotan.

But had she been in from the start her time may have been different, do you think she still would have won?

Not Koran

I don't think so tbh, maybe Finale at a push but

Babahah

I dont think she would have. She had a few defining moments that got her the win, and they wouldnt have happened if she didn't enter exactly where she did.

Yes, especially considering who she was up against :worry:

I still think she would have won as Lotan would not have impressed himself as gang leader on her like he did the others. Isabelle deserved her win whatever day she went in.

Raph shade? Oh my

I think she deserved it definitely. I just wonder would she have been blended into the background a bit more if she entered like everyone else. I feel she made her mark because she came in was new and completely took down Lotan without any effort.

Would that have happened had they lived together since day 1? I'm not sure.

Her taking down Lotan was her defining moment and if not for that, I can tell you, she would have not won it and would have probably been evicted over Chanelle at the double eviction on Day 47, or even earlier perhaps. Chanelle would probably have won had Izzy entered on Day 1...gotta agree with some of u. Regardless, Izzy was a deserving winner

Sadly no. There needed to be those two and a half weeks of Lotan gradually gaining control over the house and gradually turning out to be vile over time, as he was hiding who he really was up until near the time she entered. Her entering is what pushed him to make her his target after he gained enough control to. That's not necessarily a bad thing. It's just much more helpful towards her and her six-day long take-down of him was the setting up for her complex storyline of being a selfless sweet girl self-conscious about who she is who would then be rewarded as proof she deserves it. I'm glad when she debuted as I much preferred her over the other possible winners in Raph and Deborah, much as I liled all three.

Issy was a deserving winner, and let's not talk about this, what if cause i really hate thinking of a different winner than Issy

It's just a discussion that's interesting as it could have been different.

But then why is Raph in your profile faves Nicky :laugh: