Delete
 

Delete

liam - he runs rings round noel:shrug:

both absolute TRASH

Both a pair of twats

Liam.

Noel is a pretentious dickhead.

Noel is more talented, isn't he?

Both of them pretty much suck. ;)

Both have anger issues and massive chips on their shoulders.

calm down brunt - you are going to bust a vein with your posts :laugh:

Has to be Liam really

Yeah but Liam made Oasis I think

Sam Gallagher.

This! Liam's just "normal" and actually, quite shy. Noel likes the sound of his own voice it seems.

I'd just put Noel ahead.

Hated luam but loved noel in the 90s...love liam and hate noel now...he wears skinny jeans.

Ian

In my opinion, the best part of both of them was the bit the midwife dropped in a bucket.

They made some incredibly great songs and still are.
Not one of their songs recorded by anyone else,in my view,comes near to their original performance.

No surprise that they are one of the greatest groups ever,as to the songs they wrote recorded and performed.

I'd still edge Noel ahead as to most talented but Liam's performances,such as on great songs like 'wonderwall,Whatever and the brilliant Champagne Supernova are exceptional.

I used to enjoy the discussions on here with a great member, InOne,on here,another big fan of Oasis.

I'd have said Noel any day because of the music he created... until his conduct last year with the One Love benefit. Not even arsed to show up because of this petty feud. And Liam has been a scream on twitter for a while so I prefer him now.

Liam

Rory