Which of the following BBUS winners are considered the worst?
 

Poll incoming...

These three winners are often considered the worst BBUS winners in terms of GAMEPLAY. So, who is the worst?

BTW: This is not on personality wise...

Evil dick and Andy

Excuse you I love Jordan

Haven't seen any of those series tho

Jordan out of those options. I liked Adam & Steve as winners.

Jordan out of them 3

I would say evil dick and rachel are the worst as their wins are the most tainted due to rigging that help them

Yeah and I'm not the biggest fan of either of them in general either (although I somewhat liked Rachel in BB13 --- and I didn't mind her all that much in BB12 tbf).

I'll rank them all cause why not:

Dan BB10
Mike BB7
Josh BB19
Dr. Will BB2
Nicole BB18
Morgan BBOTT
Hayden BB12
Derrick BB16
Adam BB9
Steve BB17
Jun BB4
Ian BB14
Rachel BB13
Maggie BB6 (could mix around Ian to Maggie in any order really)
Marissa CBBUS
Dick BB8
Jordan BB11
Andy BB15

Included Will because I saw BB7 & half of BB2 and threw Jun in there since I saw some of BB4 and generally know what she's kind of like.

Adam, Derrick and Boogie are the axis of evil.

I dont get why people have Andy so low down, yes he was not a nice person but he played his arse off and ran circles around the people in his season, I would rank him top 5 tbh.

Evel Dick's win was rigged and he was an awful person so I'd say him

Josh is the worst winner. But out of those 3 I guess Adam.

tea

I don't think Adam was a bad strategic player. He sorta let Ryan take the fall for everything while he maintained strong relationships with everybody, similar to how Dan let Memphis take the fall for everything in the endgame of BB10.

Steve wasn't a bad player necessarily, just a boring gameplayer. Worst three I think would probably be Josh, Rachel and Jordan

Rachel Reilly is the worst in terms of gameplay. Her social game was awful and she relied on all three production twists to make it to the end.

Adam wasn't a bad player at all either...

Adam, he was a nasty person. Also Evil Dick I hated the way he treated Jen.

Ranking the winners based on my faves [not purely gameplay]

Dr. Will - BB2
Jun - BB4
Morgan - BBOTT
Dan - BB10
Drew - BB5
-----------
Adam - BB9
Hayden - BB12
Jordan - BB11
Lisa - BB3
Dick - BB8
-------------
Ian - BB14
Derrick - BB16
Maggie - BB6
Steve - BB17
-------------
Rachel - BB13
Marissa - CBB
Boogie - BB7
Josh - BB19
Nicole - BB18
Andy - BB15

Ranking based on gameplay purely [and no personal feelings at all]

I put Derrick first because he controlled every single vote, every single person and everyone loved him. He also made Victoria a tag along and somehow got Cody to take him to F2 - Dan was in trouble pre jury, Derrick was never in trouble, which is why Derrick could be considered better objectively.

Andy was also never in trouble and was a little rat. Everyone liked him/trusted him and even Elissa thought McCrae may have voted out Amanda.

Dan of course third. Being the first player to win 7-0 and having great strategy

Will fourth for his charm alone, although early game he was in danger.

Maggie fifth for her control of the nerd herd and having every single person in her alliance worship her and get Ivette/April etc to prefer Maggie to their own lifelong friends and somehow getting Howie to vote out his own alliance to end their whole alliance. They are probably the best 5 players.

Derrick [BB16]
Andy [BB15]
Dan [BB10]
Will [BB2]
Maggie [BB6]
Hayden [BB12]
Jun [BB4]
Drew [BB5]
Lisa [BB3]
Ian [BB14]
Adam [BB9]
Steve [BB17]
Morgan [BBOTT]
Boogie [BB7]
Nicole [BB18]
Dick [BB8]
Jordan [BB11]
Marissa [CBB]
Josh [BB19]
Rachel [BB13]

Oh I ranked mine based on favorites... didn't realize this thread was about gameplay until now.

I'll go with something like this for gameplay:

1. Derrick BB16 (honestly the perfect game... easy cast maybe but he very well could've done the same thing on other seasons, extremely tactical yet relatable and comforting to people.. I mean his job is perfect practice for this type of game)

2. Dan BB10 (legend; from nothing to the guy calling the shots in unique ways)

3. Dr. Will BB2 (I stopped watching just after Boogie's eviction in BB2 but the fact he wins in his situation after Boogie goes + how good he was in BB7 tells me he's at least here if not #1 or #2)

4. Andy BB15 (annoying to watch but phenomenal rat game)

5. Maggie BB6 (very impressive, controlled her own side while even controlling the OPPOSING side enough to take out one of their own allies and keeping herself off the radar despite being the ring leader.. easily deserved it out of the Nerd Herd and really anyone in that house tbh)

6. Mike BB7 (very solid Robin to Dr. Will and that's still worth praise for his gameplay)

7. Hayden BB12 (solid player, had great relationships and took the right person to the end)

8. Morgan BBOTT (a lot of fight in her and a great comeback after early adversity, played a loyal game while making herself look less threatening than the others in her group so she was kinda untouchable... and just being likable counts here for the fan voting)

9. Steve BB17 (major floater game but he did it well and the fact he did this not long after Ian won is worth a good amount of credit)

10. Nicole BB18 (pretty big target yet she weaseled and snaked her way through which was impressive)

11. Adam BB9 (kinda felt like he was learning the game on the spot but he was decent enough, not much to say although he also seemed to know to lay low and let others take the fall as said earlier)

12. Josh BB19 (even though he played wreckless and wild and extremely emotional, he did know what he was doing a little bit and used his image to his advantage so gotta give some props there and that's why I don't rank him completely at the bottom)

13. Ian BB14 (good but a bit messy.. I think he thought he was doing more than he was but others were completely pulling the strings.. and Dan should've won)

14. Rachel BB13 (she improved at the game after BB12 but some favorable twists [Brendon returning, pandora's box, maybe something else idr] benefited her a ton)

15. Dick BB8 (objectively only won because of a twist & being in a pair but he's way too in-your-face and angry/emotional to ever win again)

16. Marissa CBBUS (honestly what did she do lol? she had a hard time deciding what to do all the time, she hurt her own game for others, particularly Ross, and she was the typical goat in a regular season but it worked in a celebrity version --- it's hardly even a justified bitter jury situation as Ross played pretty honorably... I get it a bit in a Russell Hantz situation when the guy's a dick but that wasn't the case here :joker:)

17. Jordan BB11 (rode Jeff's coattails and then got dragged to the end, won a big HOH & somehow got a very strange jury voting in her favor despite having the typical 2nd place speech/resume/etc. and not even having THAT great bonds with the jury? :shrug:)

Not going to rank Jun this time as I didn't see enough of her gameplay.

Yeah I didn't read the thread properly. Andy's definitely a top 5 gameplayer :joker: