Kelly Clarkson vs Leona Lewis
 

Kelly has long been seen as the poster girl for the Idol franchise while Leona is the biggest success story of the X Factor franchise.

But which one is the better one?

The one with a career and more than one hit single... Ms Clarkson.

Kelly didn't release the greatest song of all time Bleeding Love

Kelly outsold!

both alright but Kelly has some good songs (before 2009)

One Direction are the biggest success story of the X Factor

I love Leona but Kelly queen >>>

They are not though

i like leona more

Erm, they are though.

They're vastly more successful than Leona has ever been.

This

I like Kelly Clarkson a lot but Leona Lewis has a few songs that are >>>>>>>

Behind These Hazel Eyes >>> anything by Leona

That is a bop but Bleeding Love >>>

http://images4.fanpop.com/image/phot...64-300-225.gif

Let's not act as if Forgive Me isn't Leona's best

Piece by Piece is a masterpiece

Kelly there’s no competion lol, outsang, outsold, outtoured

Leona has one good song and even then it’s dated, Kelly has numerous and Since U Been Gone still goes AWF

She did release the greatest song of all time Since U Been Gone, and the second greatest song of all time My Life Would Suck Without You, though.

Queen! :clap1:

Tea

Leona did A Moment Like This better too with her better vocals :love:

Though I love both, I picked Kelly just because she has the longer staying power, and is still relevant in 2018 unlike Leona...

Kelly obvs

Leona is better now but Never Again cannot be topped

Kelly has had huge success in recent years in the country music genre... while I dont listen to country myself... she is still current and relevant... so obviously Kelly

Also she is fabulous as a Voice couch. Such a lovely, funny woman

Kelly obviously. I love Leona and hope she can make a successful comeback but it’s not likely.