Pitch your idea for All Stars 5
 

Simple, what would be your cast and idea for an All Stars 5?

Here's mine:

Drag Race goes old school.
All queens returning are from the first six seasons of Drag Race.

"This year 12 fierce legendary queens from Drag Race herstory return for a place in the DR hall of Fame. It's out with the new and in with the old, as we take you back to school! They may be legends but they aren't dead yet, henny!"

Cast (ignoring those who were on AS1)

Nina Flowers (S1)
Ongina (S1)
Shannel (S1)
Jujubee (S2)
Pandora Boxx (S2)
Yara Sofia (S3)
Stacy Layne Matthews (S3)
Dida Ritz (S4)
Ivy Winters (S5)
Darriene Lake (S6)
Joslyn Fox (S6)
Trinity K. Bonet (S6)

Not an AS, a Rudemption season of early eliminates

10 fairly popular queens.
1. Courtney Act
2. Miz Cracker
3. Jujubee
4. Alexis Mateo
5. Shea Coulee
6. Willam
7. Stacy Layne Matthews
8. Jessica Wild
9. Dida Ritz
10. Mariah

Hmmm I’d go for

Jessica Wild
Mariah
Willam (a girl can dream)
Laganja Estranja
Trinity K Bonet
Pearl
Acid Betty
Derrick Barry
Nina Bo’nina Brown
Asia O’Hara

A series! We stan!

Haus of Edwards fight to the death

I just realised what the actualisation of this would be like and I NEED it.

I'd watch only for Betty. And even then I doubt she'd stay long. "Fishy" queens piss me off.

I really like an "early-outs" idea just to give some of the lesser-known queens some attention and lip service. If we're sticking to ten queens, I'd cast:

- Laila McQueen
- Kelly Mantle
- Tempest DuJour
- April Carrion
- Vivacious
- Lashauwn Beyond
- Naysha Lopez
- Mystique
- Nicole Paige Brooks
- Yuhua Hamasaki

Porkchop can stay in 1988. All of the above have more talent than their placing would suggest - Lashauwn is an amazing designer who's produced a hell of a lot of gowns on Drag Race, Mystique and April have evolved a hell of a lot, Yuhua and Laila are pretty polished and modern queens, Kelly and Tempest offer comedy greatness, and Nicole and Vivacious gave us iconic lines.

Give all 10 queens two episodes before one is sent home (end of Ep 2), a la the Gaga episode.

Heathers vs ABCD.

Raja, Carmen, Manila and Delta take on Adore, Bianca, Courtney and Darriene in various challenges.

Nobody goes home, each weekly win is added to their teams score, and a former drag race competitor joins RuPaul, Ross Mathews and Michelle Visage on the judging panel along with a celebrity guest.

I'd probably like to see them test the waters with some themed seasons in place of AS going forward. If we're potentially getting two AS seasons a year along with a normal season, I'd prefer one of those AS seasons be a themed one instead.

Early boots is a great idea (I'd potentially mix in some surprise boots into the mix like Acid Betty) and I quite like the thought of a 'Ms Congeniality Vs Villains' series. A winners season would be the dream but I doubt we'll ever get it until we have a decent amount of AS winners since I can imagine many of the main season winners being unwilling to return.