Which Punishment was unfair and harsher
 

poll

I'm a fan of Hallie and Olivia. I'm not a fan of Yinrun.

But even I'm not that blinkered. Hallie and Olivia broke the rules. I don't see what Yinrun did wrong. She didn't even hint about who she would choose as far as I could tell. Has Big Brother published the official nomination rules?

She was asking Henry if she should vote tactically I thought.

BB also dropped her in it , by stating "This has changed the outcome of nominations" :suspect: . Hallie & Olivia ... but especially Hallie mentioned names, Hallie even broke the rules TWICE .

So yeah atleast Yinrun didn't mention names, the only wrong thing she did was asking Henry what shall she do ... but she never actually told him who she will vote/nominate.

Could have been worse- BB could have said the 2 who were up then told them all about the rule break and then added Dylan in the mix.

I’m pretty sure if she was given the option of nominating or not Yinrun would lie and say she doesn’t want to, so on the face of things removing her noms weren’t really a punishment. And the weather was much worse when Olivia and Hallie were in jail, so it was worse for them.

The thing is, if they were super strict about talking about nominations, then I could understand it, but I feel like many others in the house have had very similar conversations over the course of the series.

I’d like to know what exactly tipped this conversation over the edge. Was it specifically because it was during the nomination process, or was it because she was asking Henry what he thought she should do?

I think this was what screwed it for her , but it's still daft as she never actually named anyone :rolleyes: .