Eoghan proved he has no power in his voice and shouldn\'t be there
 

Yep, my weekly bash Eoghan thread :joker:

Anyway I think tonight when he tried to have power and go into vibrato (you know, his Leona moment where he closed his eyes and looked up :rolleyes:) just completely failed, he started to whisper and shown he has no power in his voice whatsoever. All I can say about Eoghan is EPIC FAIL.

I love Eoghan! It's a quiet song.

Next week, Big Band, should be an eye opener. :joker:

He is rubbish

He's got a weak voice - a good voice, but nothing to write home about. Next week will show him up. Hopefully he'll be out in a few weeks time, but I'd like to see Scott, Rachel and Daniel leave before him (and I'm expecting Ruth to leave soon too)

I will hold my hand up high and sayl, I was the first to think he wouldnt cut it and that he didnt deserve to be in the competition!
But like it or not, so far, he has nailed the 2 songs he was given! He was great! Dont forget, Ray couple years ago, didnt exactly have a strong voice, but he finished 2nd! And until he has a bad week, I dont think its fair to say anything about him! Yep he may or may not struggle with nabd week, and I predict that he may, but you never know. Simon will probably give him a song like that Ray number he did, forgot the song, but it was good! MY way I think!

i love him and hes great!
that song was meant to be sang like that and anyway he can sing with more power in his voice..
and remember hes got irish charm :)
ahah

Ray had quite a strong voice, I thought... But you're right, you don't need a strong voice to do well. Dionne was an epic fail a couple of years ago!

I agree Tom, Eoghan does't have any power in his voice, although it is a nice voice. But Simon has a simple plan:

Eoghan = David Archuleta
Austin = David Cook

Hopefully the public will see though this.

i dont because i dont watch american idol...

Me and my mum noticed that, he did the closing eyes thing on a note that wasnt hard to reach at all... we were like... wtf?

If you was on mute you would think he was giving a power note but it was just his rubbish whispery moan.

You hit the nail right in the head, he did it with Owen singing exactly David Archuleta's imagine, but i think Louis is starting to expose him! He made it a point on Austins song tonight, so Simon is gonna have to be more inventive, if not, Louis gonna call him out every time!

You can always catch on on you tube:

i just dont like american idol

Well i my opinion American idol is just Xfactor with better singers!

Just because someone doesn't belt doesn't mean they can't sing.

yeah people in america tend to sing much better than we do... much bigger country .. bigger talent
i just cant stand americans thats why i dont watch it haha and i dont like the way they dont really do anything when they sing like the stage is tiny

Trouble is Eoghan isn't anywhere near as good as Archuleta.

As for Austin, he might have got the same arrangement as David Cook but he's got a totally different voice.

thats funny because Diana doesnt have the strongest voice either yet you were quick to slam her for it

He can sing, but compared withothers there, he is nowhere near as good as them, Louis saying he will be in the final 3? wtf! there are by far better singers there then him.

Frodo Baggins hasnt got the best voice, he gets the cute vote

But when you whisper your way through a song and think you're doing massive long notes ... :thumbs:

I agree with both of your observations. If you start comparing them to their American Idol equivalents they both fall a long way of the mark.

That is the problem with they might have good points, but neither of them are world class singers. And in the case of Eoghan his voice isn't strong and he is going to find it hard next week.

I thought that until she sang this week. Her voice does have more power than I thought it did and it will be interesting to she if the voice coaches can find more of that power as the show goes on.

he doesnt whisper though?
and he can sing with power.. as ive said in another thread with a video!
coooooooor blimey