who will be the first judge to lose all there acts
 

louis

Louis Walsh.

Louis, he did a terrible job in picking his acts!

i agree

I disagree, I thought he picked the right ones, he just gave the girl bands really shocking songs with no seperate style.
I would have given Bad Lashes an edgier more indie song and given Girlband more of a modern pop style. Otherwise he chose the best groups harmonywise.

To answer the question, Danni probably.

Well no he clearly has no clue about the industry at the moment, why would he pick 2 girl groups when at the moment in the industry... there are 3 Girl groups, one of them brand new.
He had some interesting bands... such as the 1 boy and 3 girls group, but he threw them out over 2! Girl bands! JLS was his only decent choice, and even that was a bit predictable.

Louis, I don't think JLS are as strong as he thinks but I do like them

Girlband or Bad Lashes should have never got through. 2 girl groups with 4 members is bound to confuse a lot of viewers. He might have got away with it if he put through one of them and Desire. Then again he should have put through 4 Instinct, I think they would have went down really well.

Dannii.
Louis is with us until the final with JLS

Fair point, but I don't think theres many girl bands like Bad Lashes around. They could have gone down really well with good song choices. I do think thinking back that they should have put through 4 instinct, however much I didn't like them.

Louis Walsh

Louis... but it could be Danni at this rate.

Louis. Unless JLS really hit it off big time and remain popular...

Louisss :thumbs: