Let\'s Settle All This Dannii Can\'t Sing but Cheryl Can Stuff...
 

I know Dannii isn't amazing for some people, but she can definitely sing and this is an acoustic performance, it's better than the studio IMO.

And err, the less said about the latter the better :P

whats not amazing ?

that was bloodly amazin

i nenver knew she can sing that good O.O

Danni rocks, I love her.

Dannii is a much better singer than Cheryl in my opinion.

Neither can.

(L)<3DDANNII<3(L) I loved I begin to Wonder. I love Cheryl too though. I love the X Factor.

i love danni too it really annoys me the way people seem to hate her for nothing!

Dannii is a stronger singer, look up her abba duet with kylie, she's quite good in it.

Dannii has an amzing voice. Here is a duet with Kylie, she sounds far better than her sister (Dannii sings first by the way).

Finally a thread where everyone loves her!!!! But can I ask 1 question what has she actually done for people not 2 like her.

To be honest if Dannii sung a Kylie song and vice versa I probably wouldn't guess.

Cheryl is a rubbish singer but shes only more successful than Dannii because she is in a manufactured pop band, and bands don't usually have great singers in them.

If Cheryl went solo, she wouldn't have a career as long as Dannii's and probably would have fewer hits. Dannii is more successful in theatre and acting though.

"billy21 says; Dannii has sold 7million records, Girls Aloud only sold 4.6 :)"

I think thats quite obvious, Danni is the better singer!
We all know cheryl shoulnt even have been picked for the band. It was Javine's spot!

Dannii has been around since the 80's, Girls Aloud have been around since 2002.

"yeh but danni hasn't been selling records non stop since the 80s girls aloud have released non stop from then, and she is still more successfull .. stop now ill debate properly when im unbanned"

Heartbreaker with will.i.am was a success though.


I agree, Dannii is a great singer, she's a huge favourite in clubs, just not as much of a commercial success in sales.



I think that's a great performance from Cheryl Tweedy, personally.

And I don't care who is the better singer, I luiv Cheryl and she is great with Girls ALoud, they rock! them and the Sugababes are the best two bands around!

Cheryl was absoloutly shocking on her solo bit when Girls Aloud sang on the X Factor, it sounded sooo off key.

Dannii FTW!

I love Dannii, and the other thing is you don't have 2 have a string of no.1's 2 know how the music business works do you, like if ur a singer u dnt have 2 have loads of no.1's 2 say ur a good singer it's the experience she has had that makes her a qualified judge and the fact she can sing.

Dannii > Cheryl.

I think that's a great performance from Cheryl Tweedy, personally. [/quote]

I'm sorry but that was an AWFUL performance. She went off key more than she was on!!! Going by that she doesn't compare even a little bit to the the girls in the competition this year....and she's being paid to judge them!!! Oh and I think Dannii has a great voice!!

dannii gets too much stick for absolutely nothing. i like her as a judge.

I adore Danni , I really do. She can sing very good. Cheryl is alright , but I personally don't think shes better than Danni. And everybody seems to hate Danni for nothing , or they would hate her because shes done Botox. Well all i can say is Danni is amazing. :lovedup: