Wouldn't bother me but I don't think it should be a thread that people can comment on as that will descend into madness, more a thread like the old ban list where a mod updates with infractions / warnings and then locks it. Also think it should be done from a generic TIBB staff account.
This would provide transparency without allowing multiple members to question other people's infractions publicly, I think any queries should still be undertaken by PM.
That would hopefully keep everyone happy