Quote:
Originally posted by Dan_
Quote:
Originally posted by Ruth*Star
I think they should be able to choose what they want, then the singing on a saturday would be better.
|
I agree, they know themselves better than their mentors.I think most of the song choices this year really haven't suited the acts.
I think I'd prefer if they brought back Pop Idol.
|
X Factor has a superior format to that of Pop Idol which is reflected in the ratings until this year. The only problem with this years lot is the lack of talent. Out of the final 12, there were only really 3 people that were actually talented- Rhydian, Beverley, Niki.
Instead of the mentors giving them a song to sing, they should do a short list of about 5 then call each act into a meeting, where they narrow the songs down to 2 possibilities, then they make a joint decision on the actual song rather than just "here is a song, sing it on Saturday".