[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Mystic Mock

Red Dead Redemption 1.

So far not in the same league as the second one imo.

I've completed the game.

Overall I'd say that I liked the game, but it is definitely flawed imo, it's no 95% game like Metacritic makes out for me personally, the Mexico and Dutch stuff are really strong in the game, and the side stuff are strong as well imo, but the Ranch levels in Chapter 1 & 4 are incredibly annoying, dull, and display clunky controls imo (even by Rockstar standards) and the game can be incredibly glitchy to the point where you have to redo the mission all over again (Assault On Fort Mercer I'm looking at you) so it stops the game from being anywhere near RDR2's quality where I never encountered any glitches on that game and I did a lot of the content on that game.

Overall though I'd recommend anybody that hasn't played the first RDR to grim and bare through the glitches and the Ranch levels just to get to the Mexico and Dutch stories which are really strong imo, and the levels get more exciting for me personally.