Nice list Alf,
Even as an Arsenal fan I wouldn't have had Henry top. Probably not even top three if I'm honest. I remember his first two seasons where he was very wasteful with chances.
I agreed more with the other list TBH. I think you've missed a few. Le Tissier is a glaring omission for me. To score 100 goals from midfield in such a short space of time. Gareth Barry is the other one I'd have had in. He's made the most appearances. I think if I made a list it would be more about great players who didnt play for Man U, Arsenal, Liverpool etc. and then we get to players like Gary Speed, Di Canio, Defoe, Le Tissier, Barry etc