[Tom4784]

Hmmm 'water' that's suggesting the 'in water' ending which would explain why Mary isn't with James if the 'Mary is Alex's mother' theory is true, but then how would Mary be ressurected? unless the real ending mixes elements of both endings?

James ressurects Mary, realises that she's not entirely human. He can't get over his guilt and the fact that he has messed with the order of nature and has basically condemmed himself by bringing her back.. he ends up commiting suicide, leaving Mary in Silent Hill. She can't remember this but she wakes up older with fake memories in Shepherd's Glen. When Alex's brother runs away to Silent Hill, she regains her memories and slips into a catatonic state through shock??

Who was Elle again? I can't seem to remember.