Quote:
Originally posted by Billy21
Quote:
Originally posted by Tom
Quote:
Originally posted by Billy21
Don't agree. She brings glamour to the show IMO, and I think she's the only straight talking one in the panel. Remember Niki, who went out of tune most nights yet the judges still managed to praise all her performances, except Dannii who actually spoke the truth.
IMO, she definitely serves a purpose, she got two acts in the final last year, she's doing something right.
She's the most hands on mentor aswell, as according to her three acts she was always in tutoring them, especially before the first show when she was apparently in every day, which, considering Sharon didn't see her girls once, is great.
|
I did say I like Dannii and this thread isn't about her skills as a judge, its just whether she gels in well with the panel or not and IMO she doesn't. And with Cheryl there, Dannii isn't really providing the glamour anymore ...
|
But you said you don't think she serves no purpose, which I don't agree with.
Cheryl isn't glamorous, I still see her as the chavvy tramp she was when she won PSTR, although I do like her now.
|
Cheryl is by far better looking than Dannii is and I'm sure most males would agree. But you're not getting my point. I'm not criticising her judging/mentoring because I think shes good, I mean she serves no purpose in terms of chemistry on the panel, shes just
there.