[podge2007]

I loved the sing off performance against JLS. The problem with Rachel was that she was too inconsistent, one week she could be outstanding and then the next week absolute crap. She does have a brilliant recording voice as demonstrated on 'Hero'. She could be the Jennifer Hudson of the X Factor. The X Factor isn't just a singing contest its about having likeability, that's why she could of never win but the thing is would Amy Winehouse win?