Quote:
Originally posted by Billy
Rachel just wasn't manageable. Even SHE couldnt get her song choices right. Her songs were good, Rachel was just c**p at them.
|
True. I even alluded to the fact in my post. I think Simon wouldn't have taken any cr*p off Rachel so maybe he'd have done a better job with her. In fact, I think it was a mistake to put Rachel into the final 12. I often wonder how it would have turned out if Rachel was voted off early on and one of Louis' girl groups had been given a chance in the show.
Quote:
|
Daniel got great choices for a middle of the road contestant, and Ruths choices were outstanding from Week Four onwards.
|
I think Ruths song choices didnt necessarily get better; Its more that she put a soft rock slant on every song she was given.