How much of an influence do you think the judges comments have over the voting public. I have wondered this for weeks now and just after watching Zoe be thrown off Pop Idol I thought I would address this issue on the forum.
It seems whenever the judges give comments after someone sings the person who they "say" sings badly goes that evening. Is it right to say that the judges choose who they want.
I haven't agreed with some of the comments that the judges make but I think its unfair that (like today) they praise 3 and not the other one (in this case Zoe) and she left, same has happened with a lot of others, Laura etc.
So do you think the judges comments influence the final vote?
Vote in the poll and reply with your comments!
Mark
