[Romantic Old Bird]

Time for my Scrooge act I'm afraid.


Every time I have looked at this series, I have heard largely poor vocal performances. These are followed by squirmingly overwrought lacrimal acrobatics by Davina, Waterman et al as the contestants mercifully dwindle in numbers week by week.

The end result: A weak as dishwater pair of 'harmony groups' who will be lucky to get a second hit.

I have heard the records, and they are both pretty average. However, I think the girls recording is slightly better.

I wouldn't be at all surprised if you get another Liberty X thing going here with some of the outcasts though.

Winning might be the poison chalice.