Well, in terms of topping the list, Marcus and Freddie top the DS poll and Freddie tops TiBB poll for overall fave HMs, with much larger sample sizes (over 3,000). So they should be 1 and 2 to reflect forum opinion (with perhaps Sophie up there as she also was second in the TiBB overall poll).
Most members have left the building now, so it's a bit late (sample for the rankings was only around 25 FMs), but it is interesting and well done on getting it calculated!