[Jords]

[rquote=2568831&tid=147579&author=MassiveTruck][rquote=2568419&tid=147579&author=ILoveMoney]Note: this thread is not, Favourite Housemate of Each Year

BB1 - Mel - the olden days Noirin
BB2 - Brian - Every single storyline of that year revolved around him
BB3 - Alison - Just simply hilarious
BB4 - Ray - Maybe top for that year but isn't even in the top 20 for every year
BB5 - Lip Gloss Bitches - Can't choose one because they all made those first 5 weeks unforgettable
BB6 - Craig - Probably had the sharpest tongue of any BB housemate and the whole Anthony thing was the last 3 weeks of the show
BB7 - Shahbaz - Only in there for 4 days but every single second of the 4 days was about him
BB8 - Charley - She was the perfect villain, although she may be argumentative it was in a fun way unlike Alex in BB9
BB9 - Bex - Any girl that will have a food fight topless is a winner for me
BB10 - Noirin - Amazing Housemate. 95% of all the highlight shows in her last week were all about her even the haters were calling it the Noirin Show[/rquote]

I agree with your sentiments if they were the most dramatic but drama isn't always entertaining and in some cases is boring, dull and tedious.

I would go for all round housemates with all round entertainment.

BB1 - Craig, quality moments and entertainment too. Mel was more drama
BB2 - Brian - all round quality. Helen close second.
BB3 - Alex, funny moments, drama, made fun of himself. Everything.
BB4 - Jon Tickle - All round classic, legendary housemate.
BB5 - Victor. Basically made the show and is the defining housemate for all Big Brothers.
BB6 - Science - just missed out and could have won the whole thing. Science had his own group, was alone and fought off the majority. Quality.
BB7 - Aisleyne, Pete, Glyn, Richard - too many too mention.
BB8 - Brian - Although a bit a of muppet outside (sometimes) he gave us everything in BB8. Liam wasn't so bad, but a bit too quiet at times.
BB9 - Rex, Mo, Rachel, Darnell, Lisa, Sara - quality year. Numerous great housemates.
BB10 - Sree and Angel, left too early. They provided jokes and drama too. Rodrigo would probably be the one who gave us everything, Sophie close next. No drama but she gave the jokes too. I can't include housemates who relied upon Sree, Noirin and Lisa to gain notoriety and popularity in the outside world, (Siavash, Marcus, Freddie - they would have been out very quickly if it wasn't for Sree, Noirin and Lisa).[/rquote]

If you think about it, you can not find any of the entertaining as they all rely on other HMs to be entertaining if you go by what you say. Imagine a house with jsut 1 HM, wouldnt work would it?

And yes you can count Marcus, Siavash and Freddie, when they rebel they wernt relying on other HMs apart from theirselves, and that was entertaining.