[Tom4784]

[rquote=2609773&tid=148202&author=setanta][rquote=2609753&tid=148202&author=Dezzy]The reason why Dominic was thrown out was to create drama, They used Rikki's voice going to create a 'will he get through?/sympathy' story. Dominic could sing but he had no personality, remember it's a TV show first and foremost.[/rquote]

Yeah but Rikki is similar to Joseph accept for the fact the geordie lad is infinitely better than him as a singer. Dominic could actually sing and had a great tone to his voice. I'd have picked him any day over Rikki or that American chap or Lloyd.[/rquote]

But it wasn't about voices, it was about creating storylines. Remember it's probably ultimately Simon and the producers in charge. Simon knows how to create drama, he probably loves John and edward since they're creating storylines and reactions.