[Boothy]

I voted GTA.

I, like yourself, am a massive Grand Theft Auto fan. I've completed IV, TLAD 100% and am currently working on TBOGT. With a combined 100+ hours playtime, I think it's fair to say that GTA IV (and expansions) was my favourite game ever. I love the characters, the graphics, the city, the missions and much more. Absolutely stunning.

Red Dead Redemption is very much of the same. Characters are superb, it's graphically outstanding and the map is HUGE! I really like it a lot, but I still wouldn't say it was as good as GTA. I prefer the city, cars, hustle and bustle, all the things that GTA has.

Having said that, I still think that RDR will pick up a healthy playtime, and is my favourite game since GTA IV was released. A good move by Rockstar in my opinion to keep GTA occupied until the next installment, and most probably another franchise to build up to accompany Grand Theft Auto.