[Abhorsen]

Haven't you noticed how Caoimhe uses Shabby as her 'human shield for hostility and conflict from other HMs.

Also, that when Caoimhe is alone with other HMs, (example Ben and Mario) who she claims to hate in front of her harpies, she constantly puts down Shabby as a 'problem' to her. Two faced cow. Basically Caoimhe goes to HMs from 'ther other group' and feeds them negative remarks about Shabby to mop up nominations away from her, while all the time leading Shabby on.