[Callum]

It's head and shoulders above the other two, even if your not a fan, I reccomend it. It has loooads of great action scenes.

I definitely found Jacob more likeable in this one, in NM he was such a pain and in the book of Eclipse he's still a prat but he had some real funny lines in the film. David Slade did do a great job in all fairness to him and I wasn't expecting him to because of his minimal credits but he's been for me the best director.

How would you rate all the films now?

I would say

1. Eclipse
2. Twilight
3. New Moon