[Shiner]

In this latest incident you could just about make out what JJ was saying but there was no Josie side of conversation heard. It is likely that Josie had hers switched off fully and JJ's was just muffled slightly because of being under the duvet and that he was unaware she had switched hers off. When they were pulled up about it in the DR JJ's shock seemed genuine and Josie simply feigned surprise.... and perpetuated the lie to JJ. That says a lot to me.