[Fuzzylogic]

So Now Josie is not allowed to nominate Sam along with John James and Dave.

However this punished Sam more, because the only way Sam can survive eviction next week is to be nominated and win the save and replace task.

If Sam is not nominated for evction, then whoever wins the Save and replace task is just going to put Sam up for eviction.

So by "punishing" the others by not allowing them to nominate Sam they are in fact Punishing Sam!