[Wildcat!]

Yeah But season 1 of BB USA technically wasnt really the same style. Sure Chicken George got picked, but only because he was funny, and people kept him because he was no threat.

So really if you dont count season 1, it was 5 seasons of real gameplaying BBUSA before All Stars!
I think its perfectly fine that they do an All star 2 next. I dont want them to include houseguests prior to BB8, but they probably will, just like they do with Survivor All Stars.

And with that in mind, here would be my ideal BB All Stars 2:

Jen (BB8)
Dick (BB8)
Erik (BB8)

James (BB9)
Natalie (BB9)
Sheila (BB9)

Memphis (BB10)
Dan (BB10)
Keesha (BB10)

Michelle (BB11)
Jeff (BB11)
Kevin (BB11)

Matt (bb12)
Rachel (BB12)
Britney (BB12)

I think it should be even between the seasons, because if you just let america pick whoever they want, it becomes uneven. All Stars 1 had a heavy BB6 Hgs, and granted they didnt win, they dominated the game for a while, but made stupid decisions. They couldve controlled the whole series, with players like Janelle, Kaysar, Howie and James.