[joeysteele]

At the auditions she was really good, but you ahve to take the chances when given them.
She had throat problems but even allowing for that her nerves destroyed her,at the auditions you get to sing songs you know and problably enjoy singing, but the 'live' shows are like the judges houses, the acts have to sing songs given to them that they may not like or enjoy singing.

On the evidence of her performance for Cheryl, I think the same thing will happen at the 'live' shows, it would be unwise to risk her and add to her embarrassment by putting her through this year.
She should maybe come back next year.

I also feel really sorry for Louis,he has a mammoth task getting any chance of reaching past the first 5 weeks with what he's got.