 |
Z
|
|
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 23,560
|
|
|
Z
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 23,560
|
Cher 4/10 - Very average performance, better than her lull in weeks 2 and 3 but not by much.
Mary 3/10 - I thought it was awful, her voice totally clashed with the backing track and she clearly didn't get the song at all.
Katie 5/10 - It was near enough a Gwen Stefani rip off in every way but, that aside, she did an alright job of it.
Aiden 6/10 - He did a much better job this week than last week; it was more his style I think.
Paije 6/10 - Well I can safely say that's the first Paije performance I've enjoyed! He did it well, it was a bit cheesy but I can forgive that for how well his personality came across in his performance!
Rebecca 9/10 - I was a bit annoyed when I realised it was Make You Feel My Love because they've done it to death this year, but Rebecca sang it amazingly...
Wagner 5/10 - I actually thought his singing was pretty good towards the end! I enjoyed watching his performance, still don't think he needs to go just yet.
Matt 9/10 - Wow; performance of the night (just - Rebecca not far behind) and THAT was more like my definition of "best of the series" - which I cannot believe Simon didn't comment on.
Treyc 7/10 - She did it far better than I thought she would, she managed to keep the shouty aspect out of her singing, but I still don't think it was a wise song choice.
One Direction 3/10 - I dunno what the judges were on about, I think they were very bad, the song was a weird choice and if that's the best Simon could muster for a song choice then I think he might be waving goodbye to his boyband sooner than he might think.
|