[joeysteele]

Well is some press reports are right this morning, she is likely to be kicked out of X Factor anyway if she has still been in contact with her original USA company as to recordings. If the reports are true that is.

I still say though, it cannot be seen as fair no matter the votes, that sonmeone who has already had 3 second chances and still hasn't improved in the shows standing,should get a 4th second chance at the expense of someone who in fact was needing only their first second chance,.

Near two thirds of her weeks on X Factor she has been in the bottom 2, thats not success,thats failure on a grand scale.

Of course Aiden is gone and we have to accept that,I am not a great fan of deadlock,I think Simon or Luois should have voted her out last week over Treyc.
In deadlock, the votes are for the previous nights performance, the voting viewers don't know who is the bottom 2, there is then a sing off,which the voting public don't get a vote on. Until the lines are re-opened and new votes are cast after the sing off, deadlock is also not fair.

The point is, someone who has already had 3 second chances and has not improved their standing and this was her 2nd week in a row in the bottom 2 again,that person does not deserve a 4th second chance and I am stunned Simon Cowell could even consider she did deserve a 4th second chance.

Whatever you do in life, if you fail 4 times out of 6 against someone who has failed only 1 time out of 6 then you would get nowhere and that's where Katie should go,for that reason only that Katie has not improved her standing in the show and the public clearly don't like her.

Also we don't know whether she was hundreds of votes over Aiden or just a handful on that week but what about all her previous times in the bottom 2, how many of those was she last in I wonder.

Had this been AIdens 4th week in the bottom 2 and Katies first, but Aiden had stayed, rightly Katie fans would have the same massive grievance at the decisions of the judges,one in particular, Mr Cowell. Of course Cheryl had to support her own act but to be fair even she looked a bit uncomfortable doing so last night.