Quote:
Originally Posted by cub
Sharon was an awful judge. There was no content in her critique - it was all "I love you dahhling. You were FABulous!"
Apart from how she laid into Steve Brookstein of course.
Cheryl and Dannii give good critique. As good as Simon and far better than Louis.
|
Sharon was an amazing judge - first and foremost we want entertainment, that is, after all, the main premise of the show. We only need one, maybe two that give good critique. We have that with Dannii and to a lesser extent nowadays Simon. Louis is also fantastic entertainment and so he needs to say, and infact Simon has the balance right - entertainment with Louis, but also gives good critique.