[CharlieO]

Considering the cliqueness of this forum a fight thread wouldn't have any constructive or structured arguments going on that would resolve anything. All it would be is people throwing mindless insults at each other with no valid reasons to do so.
Idea isn't bad itself just it wouldn't work with the dynamics of the forum.
Plus if a 'fight' is deemed necessary by both parties surely they can just pm and not get others involved.