[Stu]

I think it's absoloutely absurd looking on men. And this is coming from someone who uses eyeliner and nail polish.

It's not the fact that it's feminine or that it's makeup. People who give those arguments tend to be right pricks. Certain cultures of men can get away with eyeliner and nail polish. Fake tan is a whole other story. It just looks wrong on an aesthetic level, IMO. Even if it was invented for men I would say that.