[MusicXian]

OK as a judge she is a disgrace. Constantly talking over other people picking on Louis too often and saying some of the most retarded things (hypocrite aswell)

As a mentor she is even worse. She had the best category by a country mile at the Judges House stage. She had the favourite who everyone adored, and since has turned Janet into a joke in many people's eyes, alot to do with song choices and styling. She already had 2 very talented acts in the bottom 2 and Sophie has already left while much less talented vocalists are still in the competition.

She chucked out Amelia, who at 16 has a great future in the industry and was definitely a potential winner of this show and in general she has made many poor decisions with her acts and destrpyed them by going home 'sick' for a week.

Kelly should not be back next year to destroy more of her acts and the show in general.