[Pipergun]

I think the judges egos plays too much of a part in TXF to be honest. The judges seem to be out for themselves and have personal vendettas e.g. water throwing etc...

On SCD yes the judges do argue, but the viewing public have the ultimate decision, and it's a more classy setup Imo. In TXF, if one judge wanted to scupper another's chances, they could with the end Judges Vote.

On SCD, if there's a draw, the person with the least public votes is booted.

Still... I still watch the X-Factor, it just has little bits that get on my nerves!