[Marsh.]

I don't know how anyone can say she's in the wrong.

No matter what you think of her she was in the right.

Why should she end up with less fags over all and possibly none if they fail the task just so some selfish housemates can have all the fags they want?

If they are in such desperate need of cigs then they should have used their common sense and rationed their own stash. It's selfish of them to even expect Wolfy to hand out.