#91 Sherri Biethman: Caramoan (2nd Place)
As the second-to-last Caramoan Fan remaining on this list, it is harder to judge the newer cast members because I do not yet know how they will stand the test of time. Because of that reason, players from earlier seasons have a bit of an advantage on my list. On Sherri in general, she was the best placing Fan in Caramoan and is the only fan to have made the final tribal council. The beginning of her game was well-played, but everything went downhill when Shamar quit and Laura got voted out. Sherri was saved by landing on the young people tribe and made the merge, but she never had control after the tribe swap. She was seen as floating to the final three and didn't receive a single vote to win. I think Sherri's gameplay was better than she was given credit for, but Queen Biethman wasn't even able to do that herself in her address to the jury.